Is this painting Closed-Form or Open-Form?

Please read the description for both Closed-Form and Open-Form carefully and select an option from 1 (Clearly Closed-Form)  to 5 (Clearly Open-Form) for the given painting

1: Clearly Closed-Form,  2: Mostly Closed-Form, 3: Borderline, 4: Mostly Open-Form, 5: Clearly Open-Form

 

Do not submit the response without understanding the difference between the two art principles.
If you are not a proficient English speaker, please don't accept this HIT.
Thanks a lot for your hard work!

Closed-Form

(Clearly Closed-Form)  (Clearly Open-Form)                      

Open-Form
  • All figures balanced within picture frame; self-contained
  • Composition follow vertical and horizontal lines of the frame
  • Mostly symmetrical
  • For example, in figure A, all the figures are placed within the frame of the canvas. The position of the figures align with the vertical and horizontal lines of the frame. The stairs that figures are standing on follows the vertical line of the frame. The overall composition is symmetrical.
  • Don't follow the vertical and horizontal lines of the picture frame.
  • Figures are cut off.
  • Indicate space beyond frame
  • Shows Movement
  • For example, in Figure B, the overall composition is not symmetrical. The placement of the figures are chaotic and disorderly, not following the vertical and horizontal lines of the canvas frame. Figures are also cut off at the end and not contained within the frame of the canvas.

Figure A

Figure B
Source: Wikiart
Descriptions: http://arthistoryresources.net/baroque-art-theory-2013/wolfflin-renaissance-baroque.html